American Idol - Season 9 - Top 10 - Week 3

Tonight on Idol - R&B/Soul music...starring Usher. Usher tells us he's going to be brutally honest, but somehow, I don't believe him. If we were brutally honest, some of these singers shouldn't even be here!

So first up is my favorite - Siobhan Magnus. She's got a crazy outfit on, but as usual, I love it. I'm giddy with excitement. Usher tells her to maybe consider toning her look down a little - she says "Thanks, but no thanks..." She comes out with "Missy Elliot" boots, singing "Through The Fire" by Chaka Khan. I'm about to pull a Randy, but Siobhan, you know I love ya, right? You know you're my dog, right?? Well, she's off tonight. This isn't a good song choice (I think), and she struggles during parts of the song. She's very nasal throughout. It's not a total disaster, like, oh, I don't know, Lacey was in previous weeks. Or Paige last week. But it's not very good. And I'm willing to give her a pass. The judges are pretty vicious with her - more so than they normally are, and you can see on face that she's torn up about it. Randy said it wasn't her best performance. Ellen said Siobhan went off a bit, and never really recovered. Kara said her lower register wasn't there, but did say she's allowed one off night. Simon was just a jerk. I mean, OK, we know you didn't like it. But he went over the line. Give the girl a break - she's been consistent this season, and when he says, "If this was the first time we saw you..." It's not Mr. Cowell. And learn to pronounce her name...it's "Sha-VON", not "SIOB-HAN". Simon said she committed manslaughter to the song. Really? Look, I didn't like it, but she needs to keep her chin up. I voted about 100 times for ya Siobhan, and I don't think you're going home this week. And now I have spent more time on Siobhan this one week than I have on several other contestants this entire season. Whew...anyway, hang in there kiddo...I think the judges would save you if you were in danger, but just don't see that happening. And if you do go home, I'm done writing this blog! So there...

ANYWAY, up next - Casey James. But before we see Casey meet Usher, we see Siobhan walking dejectedly backstage, with the other singers. She's really upset about this. Big Mike comforts her. And then we go to Casey meeting Usher. Usher says the choice of the Sam and Dave song "Hold On (I'm Coming)" is perfect. Even though Casey forgets the words during rehearsal, he's confident that he can do this right tonight. Usher says to keep your eye on Casey, and I'm sure Kara is taking that advice to heart. Casey sounds good, but there is something awkward about his performance. It's good, but I feel like he doesn't totally let go. And he's smiling during the song, and it just strikes me as odd. He even steps away towards the end to rip off some work on the guitar, but even that isn't as good as I think it's going to be. Not a bad performance at all, but like a lot of Casey's performances, it didn't blow me away. He's definitely got a good voice, and I think with his looks, he won't have any problem staying around for several more weeks. Good - not Great - job tonight Casey. Randy LOVED it. Said it was HOT, dawg. Ellen sort of agrees with me - she said something was missing (i.e. a little generic). Kara things he's limiting himself - she wants more. Simon said it was the best he's ever heard Casey.

Mike Lynche is singing "Ready for Love" by India.Arie. Usher tells him to project more, and hit everyone in the room (even those in the back). Mike says that's a big part of his game, and is looking forward to playing the guitar tonight. The bizarre thing is Big Mike is sitting BEHIND the judges. Strange...they're not even looking at him! For most of this song, I'm bored by his performance. He's got a good voice, but maybe I'm just not that big of a fan of the song itself. He has some good moments, but it's nothing really that memorable. And that horrible habit of the audience waving their hands in unison has to go. When the song was over, I'm like, "Eh..." I could take or leave that. I just think it was very strange for him not to face the judges. Randy said Mike's in the zone, but it wasn't very exciting. Ellen said she didn't like the fact that he was behind her back, but she said it was beautiful. Kara said he did an incredible job, and that he got to the true emotion of the song. Simon said he can finally take him seriously as an artist. Said he did a terrific job. Usher loved it too.

Didi Benami sings "What Becomes Of The Broken Hearted" - she cries during her performance with Usher. Maybe she's psychic and anticipating what the judges will say? I kid, I kid...I really want to like Didi more, but the affectation in her voice is starting to grate. She's very pitchy at times. And it's very boring...worse than Big Mike's performance prior to this. She really doesn't have much emotion in this - at least, it doesn't come through to my ears. She has that pained look on her face for much of the song. I wasn't wild about it, and I'm predicting the judges agree with me. Randy said the song "flatlined" and it wasn't great. Ellen tries to say some nice things, but said it was "way dramatic" and wasn't her best performance. Kara said it was overdone, and that Didi has changed, and not for the better. Simon compared it to "swimming in jelly"...huh? He called it old fashioned. So far, she's my pick to go home. But then again, the show's not over yet. No matter what happens, Didi, you are going on tour. And that's sayin' something.

Tim "Shaggy Hair" Urban is up next - this is the guy that the judges hand picked to come back when one of the contestants was kicked out due to a contract dispute. Keep that in mind later on during the judges comments. Tim sings "Sweet Love" by Anita Baker. Usher asks Tim to sing the song to HIM. Um...a little awkward. He wants Tim to express himself more. Tim is his usual self - he's consistent, but that's not a compliment. He sounds, to me, the same every week, no matter what he's singing. I'm not a big fan of Tim, but I feel kinda bad because he takes SO much abuse. It's WAY too big of a song for him, but it's also clear he's not an R&B singer. Or much of a singer in general. I always get the impression of him singing in a school play - that's his comfort zone. He's not really a star, and while a certain friend of mine has a crush on the guy, that's exactly why he'll stay this week. The girls love this guy. He's not going anywhere just yet. Randy said when it started out, it was too pedestrian. But on a positive, it was in tune. Wow, that's all ya got, Randy? He said he got NOTHING out of it tonight. Ellen makes fun of the fact that she's constantly calling him adorable. She said it wasn't good, though. Tough song to sing. She said he was walking like he was sneaking into a bedroom. Hilarious! Kara complains it's soul-less, noncommercial and not current. She complains that he's laughing. Simon said Tim's laughing because it doesn't make a difference what they say. But here's the thing Simon - YOU PICKED HIM TO COME BACK WHEN HE WAS ALREADY BOOTED!! How can you really even criticize him? They picked him over some of the other male singers who should have been there instead. The judges really need to look in the mirror.

Next up - Andrew Garcia, singing "Straight Up" by Paula Abdul. Oh wait, that was weeks...no, MONTHS ago... Tonight he's singing "Forever" by Chris Brown, who when he's not abusing his girlfriend, is apparently on EVERY single produced everywhere. Although I've never heard this song. So I have no idea if Andrew does it justice or not. Andrew is up there with just his guitar - it's a low key performance. Per Andrew's standards, it's pretty good. But I still don't know if I'm wild about it - maybe it's just the song. He finished the song strongly, and overall I liked it. Didn't LOVE it, but it was much better than what's he done so far this season. I'm still dying to know what that tat is on AG's neck.... Randy thought Andrew's performance was "dope", and was his best in a LONG time. Ellen almost mentioned the "other song"....she said he was great, and enjoyed it. Kara said it was one GIANT leap in the right direction. Simon agreed - miles better than he's been. Simon did say he comes across boring as a person. He wants more personality. Andrew's mom disagrees, and tells Simon he's wrong.

Usher meets with Katie Stevens next. Katie recalls a story when she was at Epcot, and they met (well, she recognized him and said, "You're Usher, right?") Great story Katie. She's taking on "Chain of Fools" by the one and only Aretha Franklin. This song is required to be sung every season on Idol. Will Katie do well? Well, first of all, I like the look. She also got some sass when singing. She's got the shaking the head move down cold - but more importantly, she SOUNDS really good tonight. MUCH better than she's been in past weeks. I liked this performance a lot. Was it the best version I've ever heard? No, but for Katie, it was really good, and I think she did a good job. Randy actually compare her to Christina Aguilara - really? Um, no, but thanks for playing Randy. He said she was somewhat disconnected, though. Ellen said she sang it well, but it was a little too "old". Kara said it was one of her best performances, but she does want her younger. Simon takes Randy to task for even putting Katie and Xtina in the same sentence! He said the performance was quite cold and robotic. He didn't think it was a great song choice. He still wants her to be a country singer, apparently, even on R&B night. Whatever Simon....

Lee Dewyze isn't feeling well, but the show much go on. He is singing "Treat Her Like A Lady" by The Cornelius Brothers. Usher says Lee has an amazing voice and that he just has to have more confidence in himself (hmmmm....sound familiar??) What Lee does that Casey doesn't do is sing with genuine emotion. I think Lee is so far the best of the night. His voice is awesome during this song - he shows why many consider him to be one of the top picks to win it all. I can hear that voice on the radio. He's kinda like "Daughtry-light", but I don't mean that as an insult to Lee. I think he was terrific tonight, and easily deserves to stay around another week! Randy said it was unbelievable - best he's heard in weeks. Ellen said it was unbelievable. Kara said it was amazing. Simon said Lee had a "moment" - one that will change Lee's life forever going forward. Lee then proceeds to eat the guitar pick. What was that all about? Don't worry - he spit it out...

Crystal Bowersox is up next, performing "Midnight Train To Georgia" by Gladys Knight and the Pips. Crystal's secret is playing the piano this week - and Usher figures that out. He said the song fits Crystal perfectly. He said she has a "real shot, kid..." When the song starts, I'm not sure about the decision to play the piano. She's got cheesy backup singers right near the piano, and it's a bit much. But I'm a fool to even question Crystal - she AGAIN slays it. She eventually gets up from the piano, and that's when the song really picks up. She still looks a little uncomfortable without her guitar, but her vocals are spot on. She is clearly the front runner in my mind (hey, I still love ya Siobhan, but I gotta give Crystal her props). Great, great job tonight! She never disappoints. Even Sue Sylvester loves it. Randy, Ellen, Kara and Simon all gush - although Simon did have a problem with the backing vocals, and that she didn't look comfortable on the piano. He said that she shouldn't let the process change her - what are you talking about Simon? It's R&B night!! She is not an R&B singer, and I think she did an amazing job. Simon sometimes sounds like he's on crack with these types of comments.

Aaron Kelly is the last performer tonight and he sings "Ain't No Sunshine" by Bill Withers (I think it's Bill Withers...right?) The thing I hate about this song is the sheer number of times he says "I Know, I Know, I Know, I Know, I Know..." WE KNOW YOU KNOW!! I really don't care for this song. Aaron's performance is pitchy and doesn't really have a solid quality to it. He sounds unsure of himself often throughout the song. His voice just isn't smooth enough to carry the song. Randy said it was just "alright" with him. Ellen said it was a good job. Kara liked it - didn't love it. Simon said it wasn't as good as last week, but he says for a second time in so many weeks that there is no chance Aaron is going home. Does Simon know something we don't? Is he cookin' the books for Aaron?

So to sum up: Siobhan is still my girl, Lee and Crystal were clearly the best tonight in my opinion, and I think Didi is going home. It wouldn't shock me to see Siobhan in the bottom 3, but I'm confident she's staying. She BETTER be staying....

Good night for now - that was one of my longer posts, eh? :^)

American Idol - Season 9 - Top 11 - Week 2

It seems like AGES since I've written my last post, but maybe that's because I was "short" last week. Which means I didn't write "War and Peace"; instead, I wrote something more akin to one of the "Mr. Men" books. That is - very brief, but to the point.

As I'm writing this, I'm listening to Gerard Butler singing the Doors on The Tonight Show - you know, his version of "LA Woman" was better than some of the performances tonight. And that's just sad.

Tonight's theme is "Billboard #1's" - there was a rumor it was going to be "Teen Week" (whatever THAT means), and the fact that Miley Cyrus is the guest mentor may lend some credence to that rumor. There are two types of mentors for our Idols (wow, that sounds pathetic). One is the type who gushes about all the contestants and says how wonderful they are. The other is the type who offers criticisms when noted, and tells it like it is. But let's face it - unless they find Simon's twin, they normally won't have the latter type of mentor. So Miley smiles, offers her advice, and tells everyone that she believes in them. That's cool - I mean, some of these "Idols" need all the help they can get. Even if it's just pumpin' sunshine where the sun don't shine.

The first thing I notice when the "Idols" come out (OK, I'll stop saying that...) is that Siobhan's hair is wild. She looks like she's got a Mohawk in the beginning. Then when I see her again, she looks like she could be subbing for Sheena Easton in the "Strut" video circa 1984. Which is about 6 years BEFORE she was born.

Oh yeah...there are other contestants too.

Anyway, let's get right into it, shall we? After all, I have to wrap this up so I can vote soon. And the next episode is just around the corner!

First up - Lee DeWyze, singing "The Letter" by The Box Tops. This is poignant because the singer of the Box Tops, Alex Chilton, passed away last week. He was the subject of the Replacements BRILLIANT song "Alex Chilton" from their awesome album "Pleased to Meet Me", which came out in 1987, which was 3 years before Siobhan was born. And Katie. And Aaron. And all the other idol "youngin's...." Anyway, Lee changes the arrangement to make this great song sound like a lounge song. He's got backup singers, horns, etc. While I didn't hate it because I like the original so much...no, you know what, I DO hate this version! There really isn't anything that is "Lee" about this performance. He's trying to be something he's not, and while I appreciate anyone who mixes it up, let's be careful Lee. Remember Todrick? He mixed it up every week, and was quickly dismissed. Ugh. Didn't like it. The judges (sans Simon) seemed to love it. Simon was right - not a good performance. Thumbs down.

Paige Miles is up next - she sings "Against All Odds" by Phil Collins. This isn't an easy song to sing, and her version is just flat out horrible. Listen, I'm sure Paige is nice, and her family and friends love her. But c'mon dawg...just AWFUL. Makes Lee's performance sound brilliant. She must go this week - I just haven't seen enough from her to warrant keeping her in the competition. I literally had to fast forward, because I just couldn't stand listening to it. Miley actually sabotages her by telling her to sing quietly and super soft. Maybe she told her that because she didn't want to hear her. She also tells Paige to watch the pitch, something Paige doesn't do. Good lord. That was brutal. The judges unanimously agree - THUMBS (and entire hand) way way way down!! Sorry Paige...you're going home this week. Book it.

My friend Karen loves Tim Urban, but even she admits he really can't sing. My favorite Dirk Diggler impressionist takes on Queen's "Crazy Little Thing Called Love". I have to agree with the judges - it's SUPER cheesy. Especially the slide. He didn't really just do that, did he? Somewhere, John Peter Lewis wants his performance back. Again, Tim seems like a nice kid. But it wasn't very good. No power at all in his vocals. And whenever Randy says, "We're trying to find the best singer...", that's bad news. The judges didn't like it. Although I do want to call Kara out on something - Kara, you yelled at Tim for engaging with the audience. "You're not at that place yet"...So because he hasn't sold millions of records, he can't have fun out there? Stupid comment. Thumbs down (is anyone going to show up tonight? Will this go down as Idol's worst season??)

Aaron Kelly comes out and announces he has a crush on Miley. Yeah, Aaron - ask her out! Get as many hugs as you possibly can. And try to get a number. Just sayin'...oh, wait, she's not single. Well, a brother can try, right? Anyway, he sings "I Don't Wanna Miss a Thing" by Aaronsmith. Sorry, Aerosmith. While this song isn't as annoying and grating as "My Heart Will Go On", it's still the same bombast - I got sick of hearing it every 5 minutes in 1996, and I am not a big fan of it. That said, Aaron is clearly the best tonight so far (that's not saying much). Like Paige last week, somehow he belts it out while he has laryngitis. He's not bad - not great, mind you, but I think it's a solid performance (although "Angie" last week was better, but that's also a better song...) The judges liked him, and I agree - I give him Thumbs Up (just not as enthusiastic as I think others will get from me tonight...) Ellen's comment: "What, you're in third grade?" That was funny.

Crystal Bowersox succumbs to all the people who say she is ripping off Janis Joplin - I don't think she's ripping her off, but that IS the type of singer I can see her (and that's not bad company to be in!). She sings "Me and Bobby Magee" (did I spell that right? I'm not googling to check it...) She starts out reserved, but the song slowly builds and gets better and more lively as it goes. I've said it before, and I'll say it again. Crystal is a natural, and she certainly well-deserving of the "front runner" status she's been bestowed with. She is in the upper echelon of singers (this season and all time on Idol), and it's another smooth week for her. The judges gush over her (why not?), and I agree - TWO THUMBS UP! GOOOOOO CRYSTAL!! Huge fan here...HUGE.

Michael Lynche chooses NOT to sing "Party in the USA" (or any other Miley song...), and instead sings the absolute classic "When A Man Loves A Woman" by Percy Sledge. I love this song, and I think Mike does a solid job. It is kinda boring, but compared to those first 3 performances, Mike is nearly brilliant! He's got a nice voice, and seems like a very likable guy. I'll give him a Thumb and a half up. The judges reviews were mixed, but they all seem to still like Big Mike.

Andrew Garcia seems like he's in a good mood tonight - Miley tells him to put the guitar down, because she thinks he's hiding back there. He also forgets the words during the Miley session. Uh oh - that's not good. Speaking of not good, his version of the immortal Marvin Gaye's "I Heard It Through The Grapevine" was pretty bad in my opinion. I think the California Raisins did a better job in the 80's. And like the judges, I'm getting tired of Andrew. He may actually go this week instead of Paige (although I'd still put money on Paige). Kara and Simon mention "Straight Up" during their critique. Wait, didn't "Straight Up" go to number 1? If so, she should have sang that! I mean, sing it every week! Just adapt it to the week's theme. A country version of "Straight Up". A Hip Hop version. A Rolling Stones version. I just wish Kara would stop bringing it up. Anyway, big Thumbs Down for Andrew this week. Ugh. By the way, Andrew's good mood is quickly dissipated when Simon gives him his thoughts. Andrew looks like he's going to kill the poor, overpaid Brit!

Katie Stevens takes on Fergie's "Big Girls Don't Cry" - when she first said she was going to do this, I thought it was Frankie Vallie and the Four Seasons! Anyway, I know this song, but Katie's version is not good. I though her tone and pitch were all over the place. Sounds like she's singing through her nose. While Katie has the look (and face it, she's cute), this IS a singing competition, and I didn't care for it very much. But she's far from the worst, an I think she stays around another week. I could see Katie on a soap opera. She's got that kinda look! If singing doesn't work out, there is always Days of Our Lives. By the way, Randy said he likes the fact that she's listening. Huh? That's the best comment? They all seemed to love it - I clearly didn't hear the same in that performance. Thumbs down from Mort.

Casey James singing Huey Lewis' "Power of Love"?? Really? I like that song (Sorry Karen!). I also like Casey - he's one of my favorite male performers on the show. But for some reason it doesn't quite work. First of all Casey said he's going to get into it, i.e. moving around. Instead, the only moving he does is move from one part of the stage at the beginning to the other. That's about it. Again, really like his voice, but the performance was flat. Thumb in the middle - not up or down. Indifferent. Shoulda really made it a bluesy song, and lost those horns. I'm still a big fan, though. Just not as much tonight. Oh, and Kara is practically undressed him with her eyes - she's going NUTS watching him tonight! At one point, she tilts her head and just smiles wide eyed at Casey.

Didi Benami - or, Didi Binimi as Ryan said, takes on "You're No Good" by Linda Ronstadt. It was also done by Van Halen in 1979 on VH II. That's for you, Eludius. Anyway, there is something kinda cool about Didi's voice, but some people will hate it. I do agree with Kara that she (Binimi) took on a persona while singing. Like she was trying out for a Broadway show. And what's with the mean faces? While overall I didn't care for the song, I didn't think it was a bad as the judges thought. And the fact that Simon compares her to Lacey Brown...well, that's just an insult to Didi! I'll give it another thumbs in the middle - not horrible, but not great either.

My favorite goes last tonight - my girl Siobhan Magnus. I love those glasses. And that smile. And that voice. And the fact that she's so different. I honestly watch Idol primarily to see what she'll come up with every week. It's funny - she sings "Superstitious" by Stevie Wonder, but as I said, she looks like Sheena Easton! She does well singing Stevie, because she also sang "Livin' For the City" during Hollywood and blew the roof off. Of course, I'm biased, and you all probably think I can't write anything bad about Siobhan. Well, I will say my favorite performance this year by her was "Think" by Aretha Franklin, but this was close. She rocks it out, and while she does the scream at the end AGAIN, I love it. For me, it's still a toss up between Crystal and Siobhan, but since I'm smitten with Siobhan, I'll say that she's still the top in my book by a slight margin. Just don't get your septum pierced...please?

I would love to see Crystal vs Siobhan - see one of my earlier posts - in the final. Sure, I put Casey up there in the pool I'm in, but I don't care. Siobhan rocks...and she didn't do anything this week to cause me to think otherwise.

My prediction on who goes this week? Paige or Andrew. I'm picking Paige. Although I also think Didi is in the bottom 3, and she could be gone instead. But clearly Paige deserves to go home.

Until next week...have a good one! Keep your feet on the ground, and keep reaching for the stars! :^) Oh, and Demi Lovato is supposed to be performing live tomorrow. So make sure you tune in...

American Idol - Season 9 - Top 12 - Week 1

Well, here we are. The top 12. And it just so happens I'm under the weather. Caught a stomach bug and today was HORRIBLE. I'm really hoping the worst of it is behind me, but I still don't feel 100%. So with that, I'm really going to keep this short and sweet. Here we go.

Michael Lynche - Big Mike sings "Miss You". I liked it - I can see him going far in the competition. I was wondering how he was going to pull this off, but he did well. Wasn't blown away by it, but very solid performance from an artist who is becoming very consistent.

Didi Benami -Didi sings "Play With Fire", which is one of my favorite Stones songs. Reminds me of Freshman Year when I got into "Hot Rocks" (aka Stone's Greatest Hits collection). I was very impressed with Didi - much stronger than her previous performances. Her voice, at times, is awesome. Don't know if I was wild about the crazy faces she was making (as in, look, I'm angry here...) But nice performance overall, and I'm starting to think the top 12 is going to make people notice that they actually DO have some good singers on here.

Casey James - I am picking this guy to go very far in the competition, and his performance of the Stones's "It's All All Over Now". This is a great, bluesy performance. Someone I work with said Casey sounds like Bob Seger, and I can see that (although not so much tonight). His overall performance is so far my favorite of the evening. He's got the look, the voice and can play guitar. What is there not to like? And Kara loves him. :^)

Lacey Brown - Look, I'm sure Lacey is a nice person, and her family loves her. But I cringe when I hear her sing. She attempts "Ruby Tuesday" and it's all over the place. I just don't get her, and I wouldn't be surprised if she's the first to go. I would have rather had Lilly Scott as the "unique" singer than Lacey.

Andrew Garcia - Andrew has been dogged in past weeks because he never has been able to match the peak of his version of "Straight Up". Tonight he takes on "Gimme Shelter", which I'm not sure is the best song for him. It definitely gets better as it goes along, and he finishes strong. I still think he's got a nice quality to his voice, but like so many people, it's song choice that makes a huge difference. I hope he sticks around - I think once he gets that perfect song, it's going to be awesome.

Katie Stevens - I'm somewhat indifferent regarding Katie. On one hand, she does have a good voice. On the other, I never get the impression that she's going to be a star. She takes on "Wild Horses", a song that I thought my girl Siobhan would be natural at taking on. She does better than I thought - especially after the beginning of the song. Not bad, but it's not something in particular that's especially memorable. And with that song, you have an opportunity to make your moment, and I don't know if she did.

Tim Urban - Tim sings "Under My Thumb", which I like as an original Stones song. I don't like it as a Reggae/Lounge song, which Tim turns it into. Horrible arrangement, and does nothing to showcase his voice. Blah. Not a fan, and he would be in my bottom 2 so far (along with Lacey). Sorry Dirk.

Siobhan Magnus - You all know how I feel about Siobhan. Along with Crystal, she's my personal favorite on this show. She sings "Paint It Black" (one of my favorite Stones songs...of course), and it starts out SLLLLLOOOOOWWW. Almost like a completely different song. I'm waiting for the drums to kick in, but they never really do. She does pick up the song, though, and it ends up being really good. I've heard better performances from her, but really, I'm nitpicking here. And the signature super high note/scream at the end....love it! Did I mention she looks AWESOME tonight? I'm so glad she's on this show. I really can't say how much I like...no, LOVE Siobhan!! She rocks...totally. Oh, and I love those glasses, too. :^)

Lee Dewyze - Singing "Beast of Burden", Lee cements his status as a major contender. I would not be surprised if he goes on to win the whole thing. He's got that Daughtry type of star voice. You just know he's going to be successful, and I think the experience he gets through this competition will only make him stronger. Definitely a fan of Lee.

Paige Miles - She sings "Honkey Tonk Woman", and generally does a good job. In fact, there are moments which are quite stunning. We learn afterwards she has laryngitis! What?!!? I have been down on Paige in the past, but I enjoyed this performance.

Aaron Kelly - Aaron takes on "Angie", and like the judges said, it's the perfect song choice for him. He brings a slight country edge to the song. And while his hair can be a little distracting (yes, very "Ellen" like...), I thought he did a good job. I'm still amazed that this kid is 16 - he has his highs and lows, and I thought this week was definitely a high. Good job Aaron.

Crystal Bowersox - Along with Siobhan, Crystal is my favorite almost from day 1. She sings "You Can't Always Get What You Want", and again, it just appears effortless. I think she's been better in past weeks, but when you're this good, it really doesn't matter. She is clearly in the top half of the singers and is my pick to win the whole thing. I still like Siobhan a little better, but only because I'm always wondering what she's going to do each week. I almost expect Crystal to pull of a professional performance each week. I'm never disappointed. Great job Crystal!

So for me, the winners of the night are Siobhan and Crystal. Casey, Lee, Didi, Big Mike, and Aaron were not far behind. Andrew, Paige and Katie are probably somewhere in the middle. As for the bottom, it's got to be Lacey and Tim. One of them should go home this week.

American Idol - Season 9 - Week 3 (The Guys)

Well, today was an eventful day...we got new siding and shutters put on the house, and I'm very excited about it. They woke us up pretty early, plus I went to bed late last night gushing over Siobhan and Crystal, so I'm TIRED this evening. But I must soldier on, because my public demands it! I must update this blog!

Someone told me today that I should write about something OTHER than AI. Well, technically, I just did! But seriously, I would like to write about other things, but I've said that I would in the past, and haven't done so. So my "musings" are pretty limited if you're an Idol fan like myself. We'll see if once this season is over I can start writing some other things on here. I did have a post ready to go about my musical tastes, and how they have developed over the years. Maybe I'll get that posted soon...

ANYWAY, tonight on AI, it's the guy's turn to try to make the top 12. Before tonight's performances get underway, Ryan asks Kara why she and Simon sit so close to each other. Hmmmm...has Ryan been reading my blog? If so, please Ryan, a word of advice: Stop with the annoying pause after the word "THIS" when you say, "This is American Idol"...or, "THIS....(yawn...)...IS AMERICAN IDOL!!" I've always hated that.

Ryan says Kara is Simon's binky. He doesn't know what that means, because I don't believe he has children. But anyway, let's get on the show.

First up is Lee Dewyze, who is one of my favorite guy performers. He sings Owl City's "Fireflies", which in his version is way less annoying than the original. It's actually a nice version of it. When Lee tones it down, he sometimes has pitch problems. But then when he sings with some power, it sounds great. He has to work on that - being consistent throughout the entire song. But overall, I really liked his performance of a song I don't care much for. Good job Lee. It DID end quite abruptly, which was kind of strange. But I liked it. What did the judges think? Randy said it was an odd choice of song, but he liked what Lee did with it. Ellen liked that he changed it up, although he had some pitch problems. That's what I said! Kara said Lee looks confident, and she likes it! She thinks he made it a better song. Uh oh -now her and Simon are pushing each other because of Ryan's comment. Simon said there was nothing to rave about...OMG - he says "I don't think you had a MOMENT"...I'm so sick of him saying that line. Stop Simon! We don't always need a MOMENT!!! Grrrrrr.....Simon said he didn't really care for it, but he thinks Lee will be here for a while. My prediction: Lee is safe and deserves to be in the top 12.

Next up is Alex Lambert, singing Ray LaMontagne (did I spell that correctly?) My friend Eludius (did I spell that correctly?) is a huge Ray LaMontagne fan, so I'll have to ask him what he thought of this performance. Alex still looks nervous up there, and his performance is awkward. I really didn't care for this. Randy said good song choice, but he wasn't blown away by it. They all boo Randy. Ellen said he is becoming a "mushy banana" - that he's ripening too fast. She liked him but warns against becoming a cocky banana. Kara said the only thing preventing him from winning is his belief in himself. And Simon agrees - he thinks Alex doesn't relax and have a good time. Like, imagining Randy in a bikini. Um...no. I personally think all 4 of these people are covering their asses because THEY picked this guy. And he's just not that good. There is a different quality in his voice, but it's inconsistent and like Lilly and Lacey on the girl's side, not my cup o' tea. My prediction: This may be the end of the road for Alex, and I wouldn't lose any sleep over that.

Tim Urban takes on Jeff Buckley's version of "Hallelujah", which was originally written and recorded by Leonard Cohen. Tim sounds like he's trying to do an impression of Buckley rather than just singing it. It's good, but he does absolutely nothing original with it. Then again, that's one of those songs you just shouldn't mess around too much with. Listen to me - I sound like one of the judges. Buckley's version is iconic - you really should stay away from it. It was good, but nothing that was mind blowing. And THIS is the type of song you NEED to blow people away with. Good, but not great. Randy said it was good. Ellen loved it so much she ran up to him and hugged him - AWKWARD. Kara, leaning into Simon, said she thinks Tim will be around for a while. Simon claims responsibility because he gave him a confidence boost last week. Simon said it was terrific for Tim, and his best performance so far. I may have to go back and re-listen to it. I think maybe because Tim was so bad the first week, that he's being judged a little differently than others. My prediction: Tim sticks around...because of a decent sized fan base of 12 year old girls who think he's cute.

Andrew Garcia sings Christina Aguilara's "Genie in a Bottle" - and I really liked it! He was getting tired of hearing over and over how much they loved "Straight Up" by Paula Abdul, but in the end, decided if you can't beat them, join them. So he covers Xtina. Randy said it didn't work for him, although he liked his look! Ellen said it was a great song choice, but liked it more towards the end than the beginning. Kara said she didn't hear that MOMENT (OMG....please ban that word). She said it wasn't great. Simon is with Kara - shocker... He called it desperate! I disagree - I did like it, and I think his voice is way better than most of the guys on this show. I really hope he makes the top 12 and finally shuts the judges up! We need to ban the words "Moment", "Straight Up", "Frustrated", and after tonight, "Binky". Enough! My prediction: I wouldn't be shocked if he goes home, but I sure hope not. I really think he can be something special, but song choice is critical for him.

Wow, they're showing the Iron Man trailer...very nice! Mickey Rourke's' accent? Not sure if I like that, though. And I definitely don't like Terrence Howard missing, although having Don Cheadle in your movie is never a bad thing! BUCK from Boogie Nights... This trailer looks really awesome! Can't wait to see this one...maybe I'll finally go check out one of these blockbusters in the theater... My prediction? This movie makes a TON of moolah.

When we return from the break, we are treated to the sounds of Kara's boy toy - Casey James. He sings "You'll Think of Me" by Keith Urban. Casey has been one of my favorites from day 1 - much like Crystal Bowersox. I feel this version of the song is more bluesy than the original, mostly in part to Casey's voice. I think he does a great job. The guys overall haven't impressed me as much, but Casey is da man...I was impressed. Randy said it was too safe - listen, can we just get the judges picking the songs? I'm tired of them complaining about the song choices. Ellen said it was GREAT. Thank you Ellen! She dug the vibe. Kara said she's "kinda" back on the Casey train (I bet she WISHES she were....) She still wants to see more of a spark, but he's on the right track. Simon said the song was his second best performance - didn't care for the song choice, but he sounded great. My prediction: Casey is safe and deserves to be in the top 12.

Next up is Aaron Kelly, keeping the country vibe with Lonestar's "I'm Already There". I'm convinced that Aaron has trouble singing the quiet, low, understated parts. He is a much stronger singer when he's belting it out, similar to Lee. But he's no Lee. I just think Aaron may not really be ready for this - he's voice is all over the place in this song. Pitchy - he had more moments I didn't care for than ones I did. The crowd loved it, though. Randy said it was really good, but agreed with me that the lower part don't sound as good. Ellen said it was a tough song for him, and didn't think it was very good. Kara said he gave it his all, but he didn't really get the meaning of the song. Simon said that is RUBBISH. Said it was the right type of song, but his vocal wasn't great. It did have emotion, though. He said it was a nice song. My prediction? Aaron has a big fan base, and will stick around. Even though I don't think he should be in the top 12.

Todrick Hall sings "Somebody To Love" by Queen. IN FALSETTO! At least at the beginning. Then he sings normal. I generally liked his performance. He had some very nice moments, especially at the end. Sounds MUCH better than he normally does. So I was pleased with it. Randy said "Todrick is BACK!!" He loved it. Ellen said he was brave - but he did a good job. Kara said it was really good singing. Although she said at times it was a little too "Glee". LOL - nice Fox promo, Kara! Simon said it was good in parts, but not all the way through. He said Todrick is a Broadway singer....and then he uses his most overused cliche..."HAVING SAID THAT..." Simon should put that on T-Shirt with his face on it. So, having said that, he liked it, and it may have saved him. Note the word "MAY..." My prediction? Although I thought he was MUCH better this week, I think he's going home.

Michael Lynche ends the show covering "This Woman's Work" (which was originally done by Kate Bush and was in the movie "She's Having A Baby"). I LOVE the Kate Bush original so so so much that it hurt me to hear the opening of Big Mike's version. However, to quote Randy, Big Mike "worked it out..." He was great. I wasn't going Coo Coo for Cocoa Puffs like all of the judges, who claimed it was the best performance ever in recorded history. (Well, that last part of the song WAS incredible...Big Mike - I didn't know you had it in you!!). I think the coolest part was Mike singing to his wife that was there. I think the least coolest part was Kara fake crying. I mean, REALLY? And then Simon gives her a hug. Yeah...anyway, I say very nice work Mike, but I'm not crying over you! LOL. My prediction? Safe as kittens.

So there you have it...can't wait until next week. I really hope we get the 12 best singers of who is left. I'm telling you, if Siobhan/Crystal/Lee/Casey/Big Mike don't make it, something is very wrong with America's voting. We'll see in less than 24 hours!

American Idol - Season 9 - Week 3 (The Girls)

See those two young women up there? I don't think there is any doubt after this evening that these two, Crystal and Siobhan, are destined for not only the top 12, but possibly the top 4. Of course, it all depends on how America votes, but man...I absolutely LOVE both of them...while I think Crystal is probably the overall better performer, I am so smitten by Siobhan...she's cute, can really sing, and her style is unique. As Simon once said, "You're a silly little thing, aren't you?" (or something like that...)

Anyway, tonight I had the pleasure of watching Idol with some friends of mine, and they had some interesting points that I normally don't point out. For instance, is there some kind of contractual obligation to the word "Frustrated"? Does Simon get bonus points if that comes out of his mouth? And speaking of Simon, just how close can he and Kara get? It always looks like she's leaning into Simon when she gives her thoughts. Please Kara, move away from the cranky Brit....please. Besides, what would Casey say?

Tonight we're down to the final 8 girls...er, ladies. And it's refreshing to NOT have to listen to these horrible packages they put together before the performers go on. So we don't have to see contestants coloring. Or telling us things about themselves that we really don't want to know about anyway.

First up - Katie Stevens, who sings "Breakaway" by Kelly Clarkson. One of my friends walked in while she was performing and asked why Selena Gomez was taking part in this year's Idol? Good old Katie...well, YOUNG Katie. She sounds kind of flat for most of the song, and I'm bored by it. I was waiting for the moment to kick in and it just doesn't happen. That's not to say she's BAD - just didn't really do the song justice (I mean, Kelly Clarkson is Idol royalty, so you better BRING IT!!) Randy thought the song was too big for her - it paled in comparison to the original. He "didn't get it". Ellen (more on her later) didn't feel that Katie "felt" the song. No personality. Good job Ellen - very true. Kara said Katie has a great radio voice, but that she doesn't know who she is as an artist. Simon (who as mentioned earlier, is practically on top of Kara) said that Katie IS listening to them, and appreciates her trying. But the song was gloomy, and he actually says she sucked! Well, sucked the life out of the song...but still, it was jarring hearing him say that! Post song, Katie explains that she was 8 years old when Kelly Clarkson won Idol (in contrast, I was 31...). My prediction? She stays and makes the top 12. It wasn't that bad, and I think she has a good enough fan base to keep her around.

We go to a commercial, and I hear a really cool song from, of all places, a Diet Coke commercial - I look it up and it's called "Sweet Disposition" by The Temper Trap. I'm kicking myself because that album was the Amazon deal of the day the other day! Reminds me of hearing "So Here We Are" by Bloc Party in a Saturn Commercial, or "We've Been Had" by the Walkmen (also for Saturn), years ago. Good tune. Sorry I missed picking that album up on the cheap. Darn it...oh well. Moving on.

Next up is Siobhan Magnus. I can't wait to hear what she's going to sing - I'm giddy inside! Siobhan's dad is in the audience and reminds me of Brian Johnson from AC/DC. Turns out he's a singer, and he used to sing "House Of The Rising Sun" by The Animals (which, by the way, I also picked up on Amazon's Deal of the Day a while back...but I digress...). So Siobhan is going to sing it for her dad who is in the audience with his Brian Johnson-looking hat and hair. The song starts out very slow, and I'm a little concerned...but really, I should learn by now. Siobhan just brings it EVERY week. And by the time the song is over, I'm blown away again by her pipes. I can't stop looking at that nose ring...and I normally don't like nose rings. Um...anyway, she's got a truly beautiful voice, and I will be royally upset...no, pissed, if she's not here next week. Rather than have me turn this Blog from "Mort's Musings" to "Mort's Love of Siobhan", I'll go to the judges. Randy loves what she does - he said she was HOT! Ellen says she knows that house! She says that Siobhan is why she loves music - it moved her. She calls her spectacular (yes she is Ellen!!) Kara said it was a brilliant choice, and calls her unique and different (so true!). Simon isn't so enamored - he said she didn't do anything with the song, and was under impressed by her "boring, dark" song. BOOOOO Simon. You're wrong dude. My prediction? Mort continues to write his blog because Siobhah makes the top 12. She'll be here next week.

Next up - Lacey Brown. I really want to give this girl another chance, but within the first few seconds of Brandi Carlisle's "The Story", I know this is going to be rough. I thought she did a good job during one song in Hollywood, but that's about it. I'm not sure how to describe Lacey other than to talk about that flaming red hair. She just isn't a very good singer in my opinion - a little too out there, similar to two or three of the other girls who are also "out there". I didn't like this song at all, but then again, I haven't liked anything she's sung since that one song in Hollywood. Randy said while it was boring, it was her best in a while. He liked the way her voice broke up. Ellen agreed - best performance from her so far. Kara said it was effortless (and she means that in a good way), and this is the kind of record she should be doing. Simon didn't love it, but said she sang it really well. I must not be hearing the same thing those 4 are listening to. Either that, or they are spiking those Coke cups with something other than Coke. My prediction is she goes this week. The only thing that makes me doubt that is the judges verbal love for Lacey - could I just be flat out wrong?

Katelyn Epperly sings Carole King's "I Feel The Earth Move" while standing in front of a keyboard. The first thing you notice about Katelyn is her humongous hair, which has a purple glow to it based on the lighting. She's also wearing an outfit that looks like it comes out of a 70's sitcom. Paging Mork and Mindy...Kroft Superstars. Oh, yeah, her singing. It's good, but boring. I didn't really feel any emotion there - again, it's not bad (similar to Katie), but it isn't something I'll remember (wow, I feel like Simon...next I'm going to be telling her she'll be appearing at a night club lounge taking requests from 50 year olds...). And I didn't see the point of her playing the keyboard. Randy likes her hair, but didn't feel the vibe. Felt put on and not special at all. One of my friends points out that Ellen's neck doesn't match her face. In other words, she's had some work done. Regardless, Ellen didn't think it was a good song to wow people. Kara said it didn't feel like she was competing this week. Simon likes her hair. He said it was kind of like request night at a restaurant that she is working at, and she sings it OK, but nothing special. Not the song to sing when you're fighting for your life. My prediction? Well, after thinking about it, maybe Katelyn is one of the two to go this week rather than Lacey. Hmmmm......I'd much rather have Katelyn around than Lacey, but I think American might go with the judges. We'll see.

Didi Benami sings "Rhiannon" by Fleetwood Mac. Taking on Stevie Nicks isn't easy, but after listening to this about 3 times, I actually like it. I didn't care for it the first time, but unlike Lacey (sorry, I'm not pickin' on you Lace!), this grows on me. I kinda dig Didi, although I think after a while I may get sick of listening to her. I don't know - but I also didn't think she was bad last week (the judges HATED her last week). Randy said it was much better than last week, even though it didn't have any wow moments. Ellen likes Didi's spunk - the fact that she got back up and came back this evening and did well. Good job. Kara said it was one of her favorite moments of the show this season. She was surprised at how she made this song her own. Simon agreed with Kara - he said it was head and shoulders above anything they've heard tonight (Um...no Simon, it was good, but c'mon...) I think Didi will stick around and make the top 12.

Paige Miles sings "Smile" (made famous by Nat King Cole, I think??). Paige is way off tonight - I am really surprised, because I thought she had a nice voice, but she's pitchy and all over the place. Just when she hits a good note, she hits two bad notes. Definitely not the right song choice, and I really didn't like it at all. Painful at times!! Randy said that song is one of his favorites, but she didn't do it justice. Said he felt like he was at a banquet and wanted to know what everyone was having for dinner. Wha???? Ellen didn't like it - not the right song to wow us. Kara agreed with Randy and Ellen. It was "all wrong". Paige tries to explain what went wrong, but ends up making no sense whatsoever. Simon said it was a horrible choice of a song, and the arrangement was awful. He said this was a "peanut performance" because normally people are at a bar eating peanuts, listening to that type of song. Uh oh - Simon says it could be the end of the road. That spells certain doom - I predict Paige is gone this week. Book it!!

Good LORD this is a long review!!! Oy vey... OK, I'll try to speed it up, but CRYSTAL is up next! And wow, they are selling Shrimp at Taco Bell? I don't know about that....

OK, Crystal Bowersox - my girl (next to Siobhan)...she sings Tracy Chapman's "Gimme One Reason". Wow. Just flat out WOW. Even better than Siobhan's performance tonight. Just a true professional. And yes, I keep looking at the teeth, but really, who cares? She can SING. SIIIIIING!!!!! I really will be shocked if she doesn't make the top 4, and to be honest, at the rate she's going, I can see her winning it all. There are always contestants who just have "it". I feel like Crystal is one of those performers. She's ready to sing NOW and record NOW. Great job Crystal! The judges all love her - Randy loved it all. He's a big fan, and it was "hot". Ellen needs to come up with new adjectives for her. Best of the night. Kara said it's easy for her, and can see what type of record she's going to be making (Kara is obsessed with what kind of records people are going to make). Simon said she was easily the best and she's the one to beat. She has the confidence. Go Crystal!!!

Lily Scott finishes the show with "I Fall To Pieces" by Patsy Cline. Lilly is the space cadet sandwich maker who is so different...so unique. Yes, I am getting tired of hearing her over enunciate everything, and trail off her notes. Listen, I'm just getting tired so I'm going to wrap this up quick. Randy, Ellen, and Kara loved it. Simon thought it was good, but risky...didn't have the "Wow Factor" (another cliche!!). Again, like Lacey, I don't get her, but the judges seem to think she could make it. So we'll see. I predict she says this week.

So my two girls to go are Lacey/Katelyn (one of them) and Paige. Although I could also see Katie going possibly as maybe her fan base isn't as strong as I think. Two who will NOT be going are at the top of this blog posting. Siobhan and Crystal, keep up the great work!

OK, good night all! See you tomorrow for the guy's turn. Then next week - top 12...finally! This season has been rough so far, but there are some diamonds in there...

American Idol - Season 9 - Week 2 (The Girls)

OK - you know the drill, I listen to these people, and give you my thoughts...so here goes!

First up is my favorite...

Crystal Bowersox - Crystal made headlines because she was apparently hospitalized overnight, and they ended up switching the guys and girls this week (guys went first this week). Hope she's feeling better! Anyway, tonight she sings CCR's "As Long As I Can See The Light". She says she's going to put a gospel spin on it...hmmmmm....this could be bad. But it's not - in fact, I think she's amazing tonight. Her voice has such a quality to it - I'm telling you now, this girl will be in the top 3 or 4 this year. She is awesome!! Randy says that she's true to herself, and that he loves her! (Me too Randy!!) Ellen says she's got pure, raw, natural talent. Kara said this song fit her perfectly. She said she hit a new level tonight. Simon said he underestimated her - said her vocal was incredible! He actually compares her to Kelly Clarkson - I can't disagree with that. Crystal so far is the one to beat...completely blows away just about all of the guys, and I really will be shocked if she's not around for a long, long time. Heck, I may download that song off of iTunes later! Is this my new Carly Smithson?? Hmmmmmm....could be!!

Haeley Vaughn - Says she's nervous tonight, and that's she's going to sing Miley Cyrus. Yes, that's right - she's singing "The Climb". During the package, we see her smiling a LOT...she's just so bubbly! So now she's going to sing a very melodramatic song - she can't smile that much during this, right? Well, I'm somewhat indifferent to this. It certainly wasn't bad, but I much prefer the original. I think she has moments when she's pushing her voice, and it at times sounds kinda strange and very pitchy. The judges HATED it. Randy said it was excruciating! He said it was so pitchy and had no connection to the song (now she's not smiling!) Ellen agrees with Randy - didn't connect to the song. Kara compares her to Alex Lambert (wow, that's a first - comparing her to an existing contestant!) She says Haeley needs a good year of vocal training, but people will root for her because they genuinely like her. Simon said it was a total and utter mess. I feel bad for Haeley....then again, when you compare her to Crystal, well you can see how far she has to go.

Lacey Brown - She takes Kara's advice from last week and sings "Kiss Me" by Sixpense None The Richer. This is not good at all. I mean, this is one of those performances that I'll be SHOCKED if a) she's still here next week, and b) if any of the judges like her this week. She still sounds nervous, and I just don't her voice at all. I do like the hair, though. But this is not a hair competition - it's a singing competition, and I don't see her lasting another week. The judges verdict? Randy said it was too Kareoke and that she didn't bring anything to it. Ellen said it was adorable - what?!? Blech...I disagree!! Kara (shocker) said the song brought out her vocal styling - but that she has to step it up. Simon said it was marginally better than last week. I just didn't get it. Still no one close to Crystal so far. C'mon ladies! It has to get better than this, right?

Katie Stevens - The adorable Katie tells us she can say "Give Me A Kiss" in 6 languages. Um...OK. ANYWAY, this week she's singing "Put Your Records On". I like this song a lot, but I predict the judges won't care for her performance. I thought it was good, but not great. Definitely had a sass about her tonight - she sounded confident, and while I may be blinded a little because she's cute as a button, I still wasn't blown away. I think she does have potential, though. She had some nice moments. Randy agreed - he said there were some good moments. Ellen wants to see her "younger" - said it sounds like something she'd hear at the dentist office. Kara is frustrated with Katie - didn't think she opened up enough until the end of the song. Simon said she's not telling us what kind of artist she wants to be, but thinks she'll stay around another week. BTW, Ryan - ENOUGH with the Justin Bieber comments! That's two night in a row!

Didi Benami - She tells us she "Meows" before she goes out to perform. Bizarre. She's going to take on "Lean On Me". When she started, I was very scared. She sounded flat. But then she really picked it up and I ended up really liking this version! It had some awkward moments, but I did like it overall. Randy said he wouldn't have chose that type of song - didn't like it. Ellen loves her voice, BUT she didn't like the song choice. Kara said it wasn't good. Said it was all over the place. Simon said it was all over the place as well, and compared her to a cat screeching. I find it amazing that Simon rips into all the people when THEY are the ones who chose these people! Poor Didi - she looks devastated at the end of the song. I really didn't think it was nearly as bad as they made it out to be.

Michelle Delamor - She is going to do something unpredictable - Creed's "Arms Wide Open". Risky...will it work? In my opinion? Not really. I guess I'm so used to the original, and this one is kinda out there. Did Todrick have something to do with this? :^) For someone who is kinda in the "Diva" mold, I don't think she's that great of a singer. I was very bored by this, and the end was pretty atrocious! She even had a look on her face.... Randy liked her outfit. But he's getting frustrated - she didn't do anything with the song. Ellen thought she did do something with the song, and forgot it was a rock song at times. Said it was pitchy at times, but has a great look and she likes her voice. Kara said it her favorite performance of hers EVER. Man, I just am not agreeing with the judges tonight. Kara said she sold the song. Simon said he's with Kara (what?!?) - he liked it. He liked the fact she didn't take the safe way out, and got 80% right. She's a pretty girl, but I am not a huge fan of her overall.

Lilly Scott - Sings Sam Cooke's "A Change Is Gonna Come". I think it's written somewhere as a rule that someone must do this song every season. Lilly is one different kind of performer - she's unique enough to almost pull this off. It's a little too out there for my tastes, but I can appreciate her performance. Randy calls her "Unique" (hmmmm...sound familiar!) Ellen said she has "It". Called it the best performance of the night. (Um...no....) Kara said thank god she tried out, and will change the game. She's opening doors for unique performers. Simon said it was good, but not crazy about it like the other judges. He said Crystal was stronger. I agree!

Katelyn Epperly - Immediately I see she's wearing less make up! She's singing Coldplay's "The Scientist". She's plays the piano during her performance, and looks great. Her singing? It's OK, but I'm bored by most of it. She does have a nice moment at the end, but again, list most of the performances this season, I'm not really blown away by it. It wasn't BAD, but it wasn't something I'll remember (wow, I sound like Simon!). Randy liked it, Ellen feel asleep during it, Kara said she kinda loves her, and Simon said it was a smart choice but that she has to not be corny during her performances. He also said it was a million times better than last week.

Paige Miles - We learn that she likes to color, but that she never goes outside the lines. What the...???? She's going to sing "Walkaway" by Kelly Clarkson. From a performance perspective, she has very little stage presence. But vocally, I thought for the most part, she was spot on. A couple of moments were NOT good, but I'd say about 90% of that I liked. Randy liked it - didn't love it, though. Didn't know if it was the best choice, though. Ellen disagrees - she LOVED it. She said she changed just enough to make it hers. Kara said it was good, but she wanted her to connect to the song more. Simon agreed with Randy - she chose the wrong song. She needs to nail it next week, according to Mr. Cowell.

Siobhan Magnus - One of my favorites is saved for last. OMG - we see some photos of her with a Mohawk! She also does lip drills. OMG - she's going to do Aretha's "Think"....I am practically GIDDY with excitement...please Siobhan. Don't let me down!! Who are we kidding? This girl can't disappoint me. Wow, just like last night, I think the best singers were first and last. I really like this girl and I'm going to vote for her tonight. Yup - you heard it here. Big fan...GOOD LORD, those pipes! And she's pretty darn adorable, too. So...um, yeah. I like her. The judges? Randy LOVED IT. Said she slayed it! In a good way....Ellen loved it too. Kara loved it too. Simon said she's strange, but was uneven. But that one note was amazing, and that she's interesting.

American Idol - Season 9 - Week 2 (The Guys)

Hey everyone...I want to apologize for not doing a write up on the guys last night, but I had a meeting that lasted until 9, then I had to watch Lost (is that show getting better or what? Still no real answers, but I'm enjoying the ride!) I'll review tonight's girl performances shortly, but first, here is a recap of last night's performances.

Michael Lynche - Big Mike tore it up tonight with his cover of James Brown's "It's a Man's World". He sounded good, and didn't go off the rails like some previous contestants. Showed another side of him, which was good! Thumbs up!!

John Park - He sings "Gravity" by John Mayer. Better than last week, but I just don't see him as the next Idol. Nice voice, but zero personality. I was bored by most of this. Again, better than last week, but giving how little I enjoyed last week, that's not saying much! Thumbs indifferent.

Casey James - Does a great job on the guitar, and a good (but not great) job vocally with "I Don't Wanna Be" (or whatever that song is called...). I think if you isolated his voice, it wouldn't be as good as he's been in the past. And his guitar actually detracted from his singing - again, I was impressed with his guitar playing, but I don't think he's that type of singer and that's not really his type of song. Not bad, but retains his status as one of my favorites. Thumbs up (but not as much as Big Mike!)

Alex Lambert - Covers a John Legend tune. I have mixed feeling on this guy. On one hand, he seems so freakin' nervous up there. And most of the time, I don't find his vocal style to my liking. But there is a quality in his vocals that appear from time to time, and I think he COULD be better than he is showing. But again, like John, I just don't see him as the next Idol. I think with more experience, he could improve dramatically. Thumbs indifferent.

Todrick Hall - Does a cover of Tina Turner's "What's Love Got To Do With It". Nowhere near as much of a train wreck that "Since U Been Gone" was last week, but I just shrugged my shoulders when I heard it. His voice isn't bad, but I was bored by it. I think this guy is better than this, but I wouldn't be surprised if he leaves this week. I agree with the judges - you don't have to rearrange every song!! Just sing it, dude!! Thumbs down.

Jermaine Sellers - OMG - during the package before he sings, we see him rockin' his onesie...wha??? Anyway, this guy is a little kookie. He proceeds to slay Marvin Gaye's "What's Going On?" And I don't mean that in a good way. Like so many of these guys, I can hear occasionally in his voice a nice tone, but more often than not, he's extremely pitchy. And I just wasn't into this song. The guys so far are not really bringing it tonight. Thumbs down.

Andrew Garcia - Sings James Morrison's "You Give Me Something". I was extremely disappointed in Andrew tonight (and last week). The judges keep bringing up "Straight Up", and while it may be unfair, his version of that was awesome. He hasn't lived up to it since. He does have a good voice, I just think he needs to pick the right songs. I really couldn't stand this performance tonight - not good. I hope he's around next week, because this is a guy from Hollywood I thought had potential, and I still think he has it. Thumbs down.

Aaron Kelly - He sings "My Girl" and I actually quite enjoyed it. He's more confident this week, and I predict that he will get better and better. He's only 16, and like someone like Clay Aiken before him, I wouldn't be surprised if a month from now he is a completely different and more mature singer. I predict this - I think he stays around, and don't be surprised if he has a showstopper performance in him. Not quite there yet, but he's on the road to it. Thumbs up.

Tim Urban - Dirk does a song I think I've heard before, but I don't know the title. Anyway, when I first heard it yesterday, I thought it was horrible. But then I listened to it again (and one more time for good measure), and I have to agree with Simon - he was MUCH better this week. I don't think he should have been in the top 12 guys to begin with, but I'll cut him some slack this week. Thumbs sideways - not great, but not horrible.

Lee Dewyze - They saved the best for last tonight. Lee really flew under the radar but I heard something last week, and it only got better this week. There is something about the tone of his voice that I think is special - like they said, you can imagine hearing him on the radio NOW. His version of "Lips of an Angel" was great. Big thumbs up!! I see him sticking around for a while...you know, he kinda reminds me vocally of slightly harder rocking Adam Duritz of Counting Crows.

So there you have it - my favorites were Big Mike, Casey James, Aaron Kelly and Lee Dewyze. The rest could go and I wouldn't lose any sleep.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I have to review TONIGHT'S episode with the ladies!